Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

The Best Cotton Sheets for a Perfect Night’s Sleep

Shopping for suitable bed sheets can be challenging.

You’ve sifted through tons of fabric and settled for good old cotton. You’re sure you’ve nailed it because cotton sheets are comfortable, breathable, and durable.

But there’s more to consider.

The cotton used, how it’s woven, and the thread count will determine how exceptional your cotton sheets are.

We’ve done the groundwork for you. We’ll give you helpful pointers on choosing the best cotton sheets and present our top picks to make shopping easier for you.

Here’s a sneak peek of our favorite cotton bed sheets.

Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheet Set

California Design Den 100% Cotton Sheet Set

Casper Cool Supima Percale Sheet Set

Boll & Branch Signature Sheet Set

Avocado Organic Superfine Cotton Sheets

How to Choose Quality Cotton Sheets

Types of Cotton

The type of cotton used determines the staple length and quality of your sheets. The longer the staples, the finer the sheets. 

  • Egyptian cotton — Has long staples that make luxurious and durable sheets.
  • Pima cotton — With extra-long staples, Pima cotton sheets are as premium as
    Egyptian cotton sheets.
  • American Upland — The most common short staple cotton. It grows quicker than premium cotton and is cheaper to process and weave. Consequently, Upland cotton fabric is cheaper and of lower quality.

Type of Weave

The type of weave will influence how crisp and cool or heavy and warm your sheets are. 

  • Percale — Woven in a tight crisscross pattern, one yarn over another. The simple style makes the fabric lightweight and crisp, which ensures you sleep cool.
  • Sateen — Woven in an irregular pattern to give you silky, lustrous sheets with a smooth drape. The sheets are heavier and warmer, making them ideal for cold weather.

Thread Count

You’ve probably heard the higher the thread count (the number of vertical and horizontal threads per square inch of fabric), the softer the sheets. However, this is not always the case.

Sheets with a low thread count are very thin, but high thread count sheets can be rough and scratchy. Your best bet is to look for an average thread count between 200-600.

Let’s dive into the nitty-gritty of our top cotton sheets.

The Best Cotton Sheets Reviewed

Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheet Set — Best Overall

Brooklinen cotton set of sheets

The Brooklinen Luxe Core Sheet Set hits the mark with everything you need from cotton sheets — soft, comfy, durable, and breathable.

The sheets are made with a sateen weave from pure long-staple cotton, making them ultra-soft with a lustrous finish. In addition, a 480 thread count ensures durability. In fact, your sheets get softer with every wash.

The Luxe Core sheets are ideal for:

  • Allergy-prone sleepers, as they are OEKO-TEK certified (no harmful chemicals)
  • Cold sleepers as sateen weave is heavier and warmer

If you sleep hot, you risk waking up clammy and will sleep better on lightweight cotton percale sheets like the Casper Cool Supima sheets.

You’re sure to find a sheet set you’ll love as they come in:

  • All standard sizes — Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and Cal. King
  • A variety of colors and patterns
  • A four-set bundle including a 15 inch deep fitted sheet, one flat sheet, and two pillowcases

Note: you can buy individual pieces or mix and match sheet sizes.

If you’re still not sold and need to sleep on the sheets to believe, Brooklinen offers samples and a generous 365 day trial period. And if you keep them, you get a lifetime warranty.

Here’s what customers say:

Lindy L. Customer Review

California Design Den 100% Cotton Sheet Set — Best Value

The California Design Den Cotton Sheet Set is the rave on Amazon with a 4.6 star and over 37,000 reviews, with good reason. High-quality 100% organic sheets at a budget price.

The Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) certified sateen sheets are soft and cozy.

They’re also durable and breathable thanks to a 400 thread count and single-ply yarn. You’ll also notice that your sheets look as good as new with no color fade, even after several washes, because of the high-quality dye used.

The sheets come in:

  • All sizes from Twin to California King
  • Over 20 colors in both solids and prints
  • A four piece set including an 18 inch deep-pocketed fitted sheet, one flat sheet, and two pillowcases.

Note that California Design Den offers a limited trial period of 30 days and no clear warranty for the Cotton Sheet Set, so be sure you want them before buying.

Casper Cool Supima Percale Sheet Set — Best Cooling

Casper percale sheet set

While cotton sheets are known for their breathability; the Casper Cool Supima Percale Sheet set takes this feature a notch higher with its unique design.

First, the sheets are made from US-grown 100% Supima cotton, which has extra-long staples to produce a soft finish. Second, the percale weave with a 300 thread count keeps the sheets lightweight, crisp, and cool.

Hot sleepers will enjoy sleeping on a smooth, cool surface.

You’ll love that the sheets are;

  • GOTS-certified organic cotton
  • Durable and wear-resistant because of the tight percale weave
  • Available in all sizes

The sheets are sold in a four-piece set, including a fitted sheet, a flat sheet, and two pillowcases. You can add a matching duvet cover at an extra cost.

If you’d like to try the sheets, Casper offers free delivery within the U.S, a 30 day trial period, and a one year warranty to cover manufacturer’s defects.

Here’s what customers have to say:

Allison customer review

Boll & Branch Signature Sheet Set — Best Luxury

If you love the feel of soft, luxurious sheets, the Boll & Branch Signature Sheet set should be your go-to bedding.

The sheets are sateen woven with high-quality, single-ply Indian organic cotton with a thread count of 300. The sateen style makes your sheets lustrous, while the single-ply threading ensures your sheets are strong yet lightweight and breathable.

Eco-conscious, allergy-prone, and ethical shoppers can rest assured that the Signature Sheet set is up to par backed by three certifications:

The set includes a flat sheet, 17 inches deep fitted sheet, and two pillowcases available in eight sizes, including California King and split king.

The classic hemmed sheet set is available in seven solid colors, including hues of white, gray, brown, and blue.

Boll and Branch offer a 30 day free trial period, and if the sheets aren’t luxurious enough, you can return them for a refund.

Here’s what customers say:

Without question the finest sheets
Avocado Suvin 100% cotton sheets

Avocado Organic Superfine Suvin Cotton Sheets — Best Organic

If you’ve read our previous Avocado reviews, you know they’re big on organic, eco-luxury products. And this Organic Superfine Suvin Cotton Sheet set doesn’t disappoint.

The sateen sheets are made from unique extra-long-staple cotton called Suvin. Suvin is softer than Egyptian cotton and is so rare that it’s known as white gold.

The extra-long staples enable the sheets to be woven into a higher thread count (600 and 1,000) without sacrificing the soft, lustrous, and lightweight feel needed for a good night’s sleep.

The sheets’ quality is backed by several certifications including;

In addition, the sheets are manufactured sustainably using 100% green energy from windmills.

The sheets are available in all the standard sizes and three colors — natural, white, and gray.

If you’d like to try these sheets, Avocado offers a 100 night trial and a one year limited warranty covering manufacturer defects.

How to Sleep Well, Every Night

With so many people recognizing the importance of getting quality sleep every night, there’s no shortage of advice on how to sleep better.

However, one of the most overlooked factors is the quality of your bedding. Even if you set up a technology-free bedroom with low lighting and minimal disruptions, if your sheets feel like sandpaper and your mattress is stone-hard, you can’t sleep.

At Sleep-Reviews, we love to research, test and recommend the best bedding to help you sleep well every night. See all our previous reviews on our blog.